Tuesday, February 23, 2010

Commas, Commas, Commas

Earlier this week, we did a mini-inquiry into how commas are used.  On the first day, we found lots of sentences that used commas, and we theorized why and how those commas were used.  We developed many theories - "The Option Theory," "The See-Saw Theory,"  The Little More Information Theory."  It was fascinating.  On the second day, I gave the kids a list of sentences.  They worked with their partner to place all the sentences in five categories.  Our kids had to develop theories and revise those theories as they tried to classify these sentences.  After we placed them into categories, we did a "museum walk" around the room to find out how others had grouped their sentences.  We found that we had a lot of categories in common.  They may have been called different things, but they followed the same idea.  We also found that we disagreed about some of the classifications.  And that was good, too!  Here are a few pictures of our kids at work...

5 comments:

Kit Hard said...

I've followed your blog for a while but was particularly inspired by this post. I love your students' "theories" about commas. Thank you for sharing.

Mel C. said...

This gives me pause for thought : ). I love the music! Is it you playing, Mr. Brown?

Mr. Brown said...

Kit,
The comma lesson came from Dan Feigelson's Practical Punctuation. I love his approach to teaching conventions - authentic and fun. Thanks so much for leaving a comment - it's nice to know that others are reading.

Mr. Brown said...

Mel,
HA! Pause for thought - so witty! I love the word play!! And me on the guitar? I wish I was that good. The background music comes compliments of iMovie - I'm glad you like it!

Elle Wagner said...

Hi Mr. Brown,

My name is Elle Wagner. I'm a Photo Editor at John Wiley & Sons Publishers. We are in the process of publishing a Math Methods for Elementary and Middle School Education Textbook for College level students and would love to use some of the photos from your blog. Would you be interested? If so, please give me a call 201-748-5691 or email me at ewagner@wiley.com.

Thanks so much!

Elle